Livewire vs Inertia: Which one Should I Choose for Laravel Development?

Profile Picture of Guilherme Assemany
Guilherme Assemany
Senior Developer
Inertia vs Laravel Livewire

Laravel is one of the most widely-used PHP frameworks today. A quick Google search will surface a plethora of tools that exist within this framework’s ecosystem, and it’s easy to understand why it’s become a go-to choice for various types of projects. Whether it’s being used to create an API, a command-line tool, or a full-stack app, Laravel enables developers to reliably build robust and scalable applications. 

Table Of Contents

​​The framework is flexible enough to allow you to do virtually anything you want with the front-end: you can use React, Livewire, jQuery, or any other tool. But there are two tools in particular that are changing the way Laravel and PHP Developers are approaching front-end development: Laravel Livewire and Inertia.js.

In this article, we’ll dive into these tools. First, we’ll discuss the problems they were created to solve, key differences between them, and how they are helping developers navigate front-end challenges more easily.

Livewire or Inertia, Which One Should You Choose?

The question that opens this section of the text is entirely valid. However, before we discuss each option and understand which is the best choice for you, your project, and your team, it’s necessary to clarify a very important point: Inertia and Livewire are categorically different tools. While they do attempt to solve the same problem, they take essentially different approaches. Let me explain.

The Roles of Inertia and Livewire in a Web Application

Before we talk more about this topic, it’s important to understand the role that Livewire and Inertia play in a web application.

Both Inertia and Livewire make it easier to build SPAs (Single Page Applications). In case you are not so familiar or need a refresher, an SPA is a web application that dynamically rewrites the current web page with new data from the web server in response to user actions. This means that, instead of loading entire pages from the server each time the user requests a new page, an SPA only loads the necessary data and rewrites the current page the user is viewing. This results in a more fluid and faster experience.

The challenge with this approach is that it involves a significant amount of hard work, including writing a lot of boilerplate code to ensure the front-end and back-end communicate effectively with each other. That includes routes, security, and many other details.

Originally published on Mar 28, 2024Last updated on Aug 28, 2024

Key Takeaways

Should I use Livewire or Inertia?

If you have a profile more oriented towards back-end development, you will definitely feel more comfortable using Livewire. However, if your team includes people who are already familiar with front-end frameworks like React, Vue, or Angular, then Inertia.js may be the better choice. Inertia allows you to seamlessly integrate these frameworks into your front-end, leveraging the team's existing skills and preferences to create a more dynamic and responsive user interface.

What are the disadvantages of Livewire?

Livewire provides developers with a range of settings for optimizing performance, but it's worth noting that it can be easier to inadvertently impact performance negatively compared to frameworks like Vue or React. That’s because Livewire blurs the distinction between back-end and front-end. Ultimately, the performance outcome depends on the developer's experience and the attention to detail applied to the code.

What are the advantages of Livewire?

Livewire serves as a framework facilitating the creation of dynamic interfaces without necessitating any JavaScript coding. This can be a serious upside for back-end programmers. While this carries significant weight in the decision-making process,, this shouldn’t be the sole feature dictating your choice between Livewire and Inertia. Other advantages of Livewire is that, from an SEO standpoint, it holds an advantage (theoretically). Rendering views on the server side means content is readily available upon reaching the user's browser, potentially enhancing SEO performance.

What is Inertia.js used for?

The main role of Inertia.js is to replace your application's view layer. Instead of using traditional server-side rendering, the views returned by your application are JavaScript components. This allows you to use front-end frameworks like React, Vue, or Svelte while still utilizing your back-end framework routes, controllers, middleware, and authentication as you normally would.

Looking to hire?

The Scalable Path Newsletter

Join thousands of subscribers and receive original articles about building awesome digital products